PEACE, PROGRESS AND REMOVAL
by Robert Register

In 1830, the Choctaw families in West Alabama had made amazing progress in adapting to the ways of the white man. The women were spinning and weaving homespun cloth from which they sewed their own clothing. The warriors were forbidden to go to Mobile or New Orleans during planting season and for the first time in their history, Choctaw men stayed at home and worked. All of this was about to change. On September 27, 1830, the signing of the Treaty of Dancing Rabbit Creek stripped the Choctaw's entire ancient inheritance from them with the stroke of a pen. The Choctaw legacy of friendship with the white man was ignored. The fact that this tribe had never made war against the French, the Spanish, the English or the Americans was never considered. The “godfather,” Andrew Jackson, gave the Choctaw an offer they could not refuse. The Choctaw Nation, led by Demopolis businessman George Strother Gaines, packed their belongings and moved west. What force could be so powerful as to push the Choctaw out of their old hunting grounds in Alabama and Mississippi?

Andrew Jackson answered that question on May 28, 1830 when he signed the Indian Removal Act of 1830. Not one word in this law mentions that an Indian could be removed from his land by force. But the Choctaw could read the handwriting on the wall. When John Eaton, Jackson's Secretary of War, arrived in Noxubee County just weșt of Aliceville in 1830, he let everybody know that it was illegal for the Choctaws to refuse to surrender their land in what is now Pickens, Sumter and Choctaw counties as well as millions of acres in Mississippi.

Robert Remini, in his prize-winning biography of Andrew Jackson, writes: “This monumental piece of legislation spelled the doom of the American Indian. It was harsh, arrogant, racist-and inevitable. It was too late to acknowledge any rights for the Indians. They had long since been abrogated.”

Nothing could stop removal. Not even an 1832 Supreme Court could stop the Indians from losing their land. The first victims of this horrible legislation were here in West Alabama. In fact that starting place is less than one-hundred miles west of Tuscaloosa on the banks of Dancing Rabbit Creek near Mashulaville in Noxubee County, Mississippi. It is the starting place on the “Road to Disappearance." 

The two commissioners who made this treaty with the Choctaw Nation were at the nucleus of the cartel of Jackson cronies who controlled government offices in the Southeast during the 1830s. John Coffee, one of Jackson's earliest business partners and the General's cavalry commander 

during the Creek War of 1813, had the shortest trip

to make to the banks at Dancing Rabbit Creek.

He lived in Lauderdale County, Alabama near Florence.

The other commissioner, Jackson's Secretary of War, Major John

H. Eaton, accompanied Jackson on his summer vacation to the

Hermitage near Nashville and continued south with only one

instruction from Andrew Jackson, the man the Indians named

Sharp Knife: “Fail not to make a treaty.” Eaton and Coffee earned

the dubious distinction of being the first United States

commissioners to not arrive at a Choctaw treaty on horseback. They

came in horse-drawn carriages(This author found no

record of John McKee, Tuscaloosa County's first U.S. Congressman,

being among the the commissioners yet the Dictionary of American

Biography discloses that in 1830 he was one of the commissioners to

negotiate the Treaty of Dancing Rabbit Creek).

Catering for this gathering of six-thousand Choctaws between the

two prongs of Dancing Rabbit Creek was provided by George

Strother Gaines, of Demopolis, Alabama. A former Choctaw agent,

Gaines was now a Marengo County merchant and in partnership

with Allen Glover, builder of Rosemount, a twenty-room mansion

near Forkland in Greene County. Gaines hauled flour and corn meal

on Indian ponies and penned beef cattle about a half-mile away for

daily butchering.

Politically, the Indians from what are now

Choctaw, Sumter and Pickens counties were weakened by divisions

in their tribal allegiances. Clear threats and harassment between

members of the “Pagan” party led by Mushulatubbee and Nitakechi

and the “Christian” party led by Greenwood Leflore and David

Folsom moved the tribe close to a state of anarchy. This emotional

instability was heightened after the Choctaw arrived at the treaty

ground and discovered that they would be forced to give up all of

their land and head west. George S. Gaines wrote that, this

proposition acted as a bomb thrown among the Choctaws."

Jackson's commissioners were between the devil and the deep blue

sea. Under no circumstances could they return to Washington, D.C.

and Old Hickory without a treaty. On the other hand, they were very

close to being mobbed by thousands of drunken warriors. The

distillers of the Black Warrior and Tombigbee valleys made sure that

the council grounds were well lubricated with “mountain dew."

Halbert states, “It must be recorded that a large portion of the white

people at Dancing Rabbit were not the best characters, being mainly

rowdies, gamblers and saloon keepers-in short, the bad element

characteristic of the American frontier. The law was very much

relaxed on this occasion, and all the demoralizing concomitant of

civilization were to be found at the fork of the two Rabbits,—

drinking saloons, gaming tables, and every other cunning

contrivance whereby to catch the loose cash of the white man and

the Indian." 

The commissioners banned missionaries from treaty negotiations

and forbade them to step foot on the treaty ground because “their

religious instructions would have a tendency to distract the Indian's

minds during the progress of the negotiations." Jugs of good

whiskey near the hand of each Choctaw councilman could not be
considered a distraction and were placed there only because some
Indians might desire to quench their thirst during the tiresome
process.



The layout for the council ground was sort of like a semi-circle. The
commissioners and their white advisors sat on a large log that was
lying with its big end facing west . The Commissioners' secretary's
desk was on the south side of the log and the Commissioners sat
facing south. More than sixty Choctaw councilmen sat on the ground
facing north and formed the completed semicircle. On the ground in
the middle of the semicircle were seated seven of the oldest women
from the Choctaws who had assembled at the treaty ground. On
their left at the west end of the Commissioners log sat the old
squaw's interpreter, Middleton McKee. H.S. Halbert describes the
respect McKee had for his duty to these women: "McKee solemnly
promised these old women that he would faithfully interpret to them
everything that was said by the Commissioners in council, 'Holabi
likma, sakonla baqshlit has tabla chike,' (and if I tell a lie, you may
cut my neck off.'). Encircling the Commissioners and the Choctaw
councilmen were hundreds of Choctaw spectators, eager to see and
hear everything said and done in council. 

The secretary for the Commissioners read the treaty in English and

John Pitchlynn of Columbus, Mississippi, translated it into Choctaw

for the audience. Then the Commissioners requested that Killihota

step up to make a speech to the Indians on about a three foot high

stump that stood in front of the Commissioners. Killihota, a half-

breed chief and "front man” for the “Christian” party of Choctaws,

pitched the land deal that the Commissioners were offering in what

is now Oklahoma. He told the Indians that it was way better than

Alabama and Mississippi. There was more game and watermelons

grew twice as big in the West. Killihota told his Choctaw brethren

that children out west grew up bigger and stronger and guaranteed

them that if they “would leave this country and emigrate there, their

children would all grow up large, strong and healthy."

The seven old women seated around Killihota's stump didn't buy it.

According to Halbert: “One of these venerable matrons sprang

excitedly to her feet and made a threatening gesture toward 

Killihota with a butcher knife. "Killihota,' she said, 'I could cut you

open with this knife. You have two hearts,' meaning by this, one

heart for the white people and one for the Choctaws." She was

calling him an “Apple”: red on the outside and white on the inside.

After this episode all of the chiefs of the “Pagan” party were allowed

to speak. They were angry. Little Leader, a Choctaw councilman,

said, “Any chief who may sign a treaty selling our country is a traitor

and should suffer death. I go home to prepare my people to fight for

our homes and the graves of our fathers.”

Halbert beautifully describes the closing of this emotional

session: “At the conclusion of the interpretation of the last speech,

that of Shenatubbee, Killihota, taking a large knotty hickory stick in
his hands, and saying, 'Yakni kanchi lishkeh,' 'I am for selling the
country,' gave a heavy thud on the ground with it, thereby recording
his own vote in favor of a treaty. He then passed the stick to his
right-hand neighbor. This man, to show his opposition to a treaty,
passed the stick in silence to the next council man sitting on his
right-hand. The stick thus passed in silence from hand to hand
around the circle until it returned to the hand of Killihota, who alone
of all the councilmen, that day, had struck the ground with the stick,
thus voting for a treaty.

“When the action with the stick was completed, Mingo
Moshulitubbee, mindful of the immemorial Indian ceremony in
public assemblies, broke the silence by saying, 'hakechuma keho
shunks, ' 'let us all smoke tobacco.' The chief thereupon ordered that
his silver-mounted pipe hatchet be filled with tobacco and lighted,
then handed over to Kilihota, who, after taking a single whiff, passed
it to his right-hand neighbor. He, in like manner, after taking a
whiff, passed it to his right-hand neighbor. The pipe thus from hand
to hand passed around the circle, everyone, even including the
whites sitting on the log, taking a single whiff until the pipe returned
to Killihota, thus completing its circuit. During all these ceremonies,
the passing of the hickory stick and the smoking and passing of the
pipe, the council men remained seated in grave and decorous
silence. It was now about 2 o'clock in the afternoon. All now arose to
their feet and the council adjourned for the day.”

There was to be no negotiating on this treaty. From the opening talk
on Saturday, September 18, until the Indians signed on the dotted
line on Monday, September 27, the Commissioners used the same
threat: If you do not sign, the United States will withdraw all
protection from you and you will be at the complete mercy of the
white citizens of Alabama and Mississippi. 

To a Choctaw living here in 1830, that threat represented their

greatest horror and worst nightmare. So eventually they signed and

they walked from the Tombigbee to the Mississippi Their emigration

was a confused mess.

Ironically, the Treaty and Dancing Rabbit Creek did not end John

Eaton's negotiations with the Choctaw Nation.

On April 7, 1831, Major Eaton resigned as Jackson's Secretary of

War. This was the climax of a scandal that split Jackson's cabinet

over how to handle the vulgarities of Eaton's wife, Peggy. “The dark

and sly insinuations” of this “vile tale” almost toppled our

government. Jackson's entire cabinet resigned and for the first time 

in more than forty years of orderly, constitutional government,

our republic experienced a catastrophe that came from within

itself. Eaton had already helped to destroy the Choctaw Nation,

and now he had certainly threatened our Republic, yet he was to

continue to play a role in the destruction of the Choctaws.

By October Eaton was back at work. He, along with Coffee, had

again been appointed commissioners by Jackson. Their job was to

tell the Choctaws to sell 4,500,000 acres of their Oklahoma land to

the Chickasaws. At this conference, which occurred as the Choctaws

marched out of Mississippi, one of the Indians reportedly asked

Eaton, “Will you not let us put our feet on our new land before you

ask for it?”

It may be unfair to saddle Eaton, Coffee and Jackson with the total

responsibility for Choctaw removal. Andrew Jackson could have

done nothing at all like all of the other men who preceded him in the

White House. And if he had done nothing, it can be argued that

there would be no present-day talk of the legal sovereignty of Indian

tribes in America because there would be no Indian tribes. Jackson

certainly rubbed the Yankee's noses in it every chance he got. In

1830 a group of Philadelphia Quakers came to the White House to

protest the inhumanity of forcing the Choctaws from their ancestral

homes. Jackson was incensed. "Is Philadelphia the ancestral home

and hunting ground of the Quakers?”

“Not exactly, but that's a different case.”

“Were you born in Philadelphia?”

“We were.” The Quaker said their parents and grandparents were

also natives, but conceded that most of their great-grandparents had

come from England. 

“Then,” Jackson said, “They left their ancestral homes and hunting

grounds and came to the West in search of new homes." 

“Well, yes. But it was a different case."

“Did your great-grandparents find Indians at Philadelphia?"

“Yes, but..."

“What became of those Indians?” 

"Oh, those Indians moved away; but it was a

different case."

“Why did they move away?”

“Because our forefathers bought their lands."

“What did your forefathers pay for their lands?”

“That was a different case." Old Hickory

dismissed the delegation. “I think you folks

have taken up quite enough of my time...I

concede to everyone the constitutional right

to be as big a hypocrite as he may please, but

do deny your right to take more of my time...”

The years 1830 to 1839, during and

immediately after Indian removal, produced

phenomenal population and economic

growth in Alabama. Cotton exports from the

Port of Mobile, where much of the cotton

produced from Choctaw land was shipped,

increased from 100,000 bales (each weighing
approximately 500 pounds) in 1830, to
300,000 in 1838. Between 1830 and 1839,
1,850,000 bales were shipped to Mobile
from the river valleys that drain this region.
Alabama's population nearly doubled,
ballooning from 309,527 in 1830, to nearly
600,000 in 1840.

Almost all Americans in 1830 believed that it
was a sin to not till the soil. The only good
Indian, they surmised, was an Indian who
walked behind a plow. Still, no matter how
civilized the Choctaws may have become,
most Americans were either gave no
recognition of progress, or they just didn't
care. Ignoring every moral and constitutional
implication, the American citizenry with the
willing help of the Congressmen from the
Southern frontier who bulldozed the Indian
Removal Bill through the House and Senate,
allowed their appetite for surveyed acreage
to conquer any “decent concern for
humanity."

Regardless of Indian progress, American
civilization was not going to allow the
Choctaws or any other tribe to play
“catchup”. No time-outs in this ball game.
Repercussions of the Treaty of Dancing
Rabbit Creek live with us in the present day.
According to John H. Peterson, Jr., Professor
of Anthropology at Mississippi State
University in Starkville, the 150th
anniversary of the Treaty in 1980 made a few
Noxubee County politicos anxious. The local
committee planning to commemorate the
sesquicentennial of the Treaty of Dancing
Rabbit Creek weren't certain whether it
would be proper to invite the Mississippi
band of Choctaws from neighboring
Philadelphia to the festivities.